[Bleeding Heartland Logo]

Bleeding Heartland is a community blog about Iowa politics: campaigns and elections, state government, social and environmental issues. Bleeding Heartland also weighs in on presidential policies and campaigns, federal legislation and what the Iowans in Congress are up to. Join our community, post your thoughts as comments or diaries, help keep our leaders honest and hold them accountable.
- desmoinesdem
- Iowa 2012 election coverage
- Who's who in the Iowa House for 2015
- Who's who in the Iowa Senate for 2015
- Iowa wildflowers
2014 Election Coverage
- Absentee ballot numbers
- IA-Sen
- IA-Gov
- IA-01
- IA-02
- IA-03
- IA-04
- Secretary of Agriculture
- Secretary of State
- State Auditor
- Iowa Senate overview
- Iowa House overview
- Senate district 5
- Senate district 7
- Senate district 9
- Senate district 12
- Senate district 13
- Senate district 15
- Senate district 17
- Senate district 27
- Senate district 29
- Senate district 39
- Senate district 41
- Senate district 47
- Senate district 49
- House district 8
- House district 15
- House district 25
- House district 26
- House district 28
- House district 30
- House district 33 (2013)
- House district 40
- House district 51
- House district 60
- House district 63
- House district 65
- House district 68
- House district 73
- House district 82
- House district 91
- House district 92
- House district 95
- House district 99

Advanced Search

Paid Advertising

Bleeding Heartland
It's what plants crave.

More proof smoking bans save lives

by: desmoinesdem

Fri Dec 14, 2012 at 17:09:58 PM CST

How about a little good news on a lousy day? A new study confirms previous research, which showed public smoking bans reduce hospitalizations for heart attacks and other life-threatening problems. The Iowa Smokefree Air Act, which went into effect in July 2008, has likely prevented many premature deaths.

UPDATE: The smoking ban was controversial while it was debated in 2008. Below I've listed all of the state legislators who had the courage to send that bill to Governor Chet Culver's desk.  

desmoinesdem :: More proof smoking bans save lives
The new study appears in the latest issue of Health Affairs, a peer-reviewed journal. Here's the abstract of "Smoking Bans Linked To Lower Hospitalizations For Heart Attacks And Lung Disease Among Medicare Beneficiaries," by Mark W. Vander Weg, Gary E. Rosenthal, and Mary Vaughan Sarrazin.

Policies limiting exposure to cigarette smoke have been associated with reduced hospitalizations for heart attacks, but little is known about the impact of smoking bans on other health conditions and whether findings from individual communities generalize to other areas. We investigated the association between smoking bans targeting workplaces, restaurants, and bars passed throughout the United States during 1991-2008 and hospital admissions for smoking-related illnesses-acute myocardial infarction and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease-among Medicare beneficiaries age sixty-five or older. Risk-adjusted hospital admission rates for acute myocardial infarction fell 20-21 percent thirty-six months following implementation of new restaurant, bar, and workplace smoking bans. Admission rates for chronic obstructive pulmonary disease fell 11 percent where workplace smoking bans were in place and 15 percent where bar smoking bans were present. By contrast, very little effect was found for hospitalization for gastrointestinal hemorrhage and hip fracture-two conditions largely unrelated to smoking and examined as points of comparison. These findings provide further support for the public health benefits of laws that limit exposure to tobacco smoke.

That's a big drop in hospitalizations for heart attacks and serious lung ailments in communities with public smoking bans. In Iowa, the smoking rate dropped noticeably even in the first year after the Smokefree Air Act passed, and has continued to decline since. That trend benefits both people who quit smoking and those who no longer are exposed to their loved ones' or co-workers' secondhand smoke.

Lead author Mark Vander Weg is an associate professor in the University of Iowa Carver College of Medicine. He spoke to the Iowa City Press-Citizen:

Hospitalization for heart attack rates is on the decline in general, Vander Weg said, which could be a result of advancing medical care resulting in better identification and treatment of coronary artery disease. It also could be because fewer people are smoking, he said. COPD, on the other hand, has been increasing across the country, Vander Weg said.

Within the first three months of smoking bans being enacted, the increase in COPD admission rates was 5 percent lower in communities with bans than those without. After three years, that difference had grown to 17 percent.

Communities that had smoking bans in all three possible locations - bars, restaurants and offices - saw greater relative reductions than counties that banned smoking only in a single setting, the study found.

Areas with bans in two or three settings saw decreases in heart attack admissions of between 14 percent and 16 percent, while those with a single ban did not see as significant of decreases, Vander Weg said.

"The bottom line for that is that the more bans that there were, the greater reduction that we saw, at least in heart attacks," he said.

The admissions were only for patients age 65 and older because the study relied on Medicare data. Although research has shown that smoking is declining nationwide, it's declining at a lower rate among people age 65 and older.

The Iowa Department of Public Health has posted rules and frequently asked questions related to the Smokefree Air Act.

Because of the many health risks associated with secondhand smoke, Bleeding Heartland strongly supported the Iowa Smokefree Air Act and the Iowa Department of Public Health's decision to enforce that ban in all restaurants. I had no sympathy for smokers who whined about "Big Brother Democrats and Turncoat Republicans" and called the public smoking ban "Soviet" or "fascist."

Former Governor Chet Culver deserves credit for supporting this bill through the legislative process and signing it into law. The lawmakers who had the guts to vote for this controversial bill should feel proud too.

Here is the full list of 54 House members who voted yes on the final version of House File 2212 in 2008. I've put an asterisk next to those who still serve in the Iowa legislature. Note that while Democrats provided most of the yes votes, the bill would not have passed without some support from House Republicans.

Ako Abdul-Samad*
Paul Bell
Deborah Berry*
Polly Bukta
Dennis Cohoon*
Swati Dandekar
Mark Davitt
Ro Foege
Wayne Ford
Marcella Frevert
Mary Gaskill*
Elesha Gayman
Lisa Heddens*
Bruce Hunter*
Dave Jacoby*
Pam Jochum* (now in Iowa Senate)
Doris Kelley
Bob Kressig*
Mark Kuhn
Vicki Lensing*
Mary Mascher*
Kevin McCarthy*
Helen Miller*
Jo Oldson*
Donovan Olson
Rick Olson*
Tyler Olson*
Eric Palmer
Janet Petersen* (now in Iowa Senate)
Mike Reasoner
Nathan Reichert
Paul Shomshor
Mark Smith*
Art Staed (defeated in 2008 but just re-elected)
Kurt Swaim
Dick Taylor
Todd Taylor*
Roger Wendt
Beth Wessel-Kroeschell*
Mark Whitaker
Wes Whitead
Cindy Winckler*
Phil Wise
Ray Zirkelbach
Pat Murphy*

Rich Anderson
Clel Baudler*
Dan Clute
Libby Jacobs
Michael May
Henry Rayhons*
Bill Schickel
Walt Tomenga
Tami Wiencek

Special credit goes to Iowa senators who resisted House Democrats' attempt to weaken the bill and got a fairly strong smoking ban through the conference committee. Here's the full list of the 28 state senators who voted for the final version of the Iowa Smokefree Air Act. Again, most of the yes votes came from Democrats, but at least one Republican vote was needed for final passage. I put asterisks next to the names of those who still serve.

Staci Appel
Daryl Beall*
Joe Bolkcom*
Michael Connolly
Tom Courtney*
Jeff Danielson*
Dick Dearden*
Bob Dvorsky*
Gene Fraise
Mike Gronstal*
Jack Hatch*
Rob Hogg*
Wally Horn*
Jack Kibbie
Matt McCoy*
Rich Olive
Herman Quirmbach*
Amanda Ragan*
Tom Rielly
Becky Schmitz
Brian Schoenjahn*
Joe Seng*
Roger Stewart
Steve Warnstadt
Frank Wood (defeated in 2008, just elected to Iowa House)

Mary Lundby
Larry Noble
Pat Ward

One major loophole remains in Iowa's public smoking ban: casino floors are exempt. Democrat state senator Bill Heckroth voted for an earlier version of the smoking ban but against the final bill, I think because of the casino exemption. An Iowa Smoke-Free Gaming group is trying to rescind that loophole, but they face long odds, given the gambling industry's influence at the statehouse.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
Tweet This!

Next: reducing radon (4.00 / 1)
Cutting down on second hand smoke was an important achievement. Radon in the air we breathe is even more dangerous than second hand smoke.

Radon is a colorless, odorless gas that causes lung disease. In many Iowa indoor air spaces, radon is present at levels many times the recommended maximum. A bill was introduced in the senate last year that would:
* require radon testing and disclosure when a home is sold
* require radon testing and disclosure in school buildings and apartments
* require radon mitigation in new construction (It's relatively inexpensive to build with radon mitigation in mind.)

If we really want Iowa to be the "healthiest state," this would be a good next step.

100 percent agree (0.00 / 0)
We are one of the worst states for radon. Taking on that problem would create jobs immediately and save lives over the long term.

Who introduced the radon bill last year?

Invite other Iowa political junkies to join us at Bleeding Heartland.

[ Parent ]
Sen. Jeff Danielson (0.00 / 0)
There may have been a similar bill in the House.

[ Parent ]
HF 2272 (4.00 / 1)
Introduced by Dan Kelley, D -Newton, Feb 9, 2012

Companion to 2105 Introduced by Sen Hogg, D Cedar Rapids

[ Parent ]
Government interference (0.00 / 0)
1. The smoking ban is yet another example of government interfering in the operations of private enterprise.  Reducing job killing government regulations will increase economic development and lead to more jobs for Iowans.

2. Requirements regarding radon testing is yet another example of government interfering in the operations of private enterprise. Reducing job killing government regulations will increase economic development and lead to more jobs for Iowans.

Repeating your talking points (0.00 / 0)
1. Doesn't make them make sense

2. Doesn't make them right.

3. Doesn't do anything to convince anyone you are right.

4. Doesn't make them make sense.

5. Doesn't make them right.

6. Doesn't do anything to convince anyone you are right.

I'd rather have "job killing" legislation than people killing legislation.

[ Parent ]
I think rockm is being facetious (0.00 / 0)
and mocking mindless Republican talking points.

Invite other Iowa political junkies to join us at Bleeding Heartland.

[ Parent ]
You win a cookie ! :-) (0.00 / 0)

[ Parent ]

Make a New Account



Forget your username or password?

Iowa Liberal Blogs
- Blog For Iowa
- Iowa .Gif-t Shop
- Iowa Independent (archive)
- Iowa Policy Points
- Iowa Starting Line
- Iowans for a Future That Doesn't Suck
- John Deeth
Iowa Conservative Blogs
- Hawkeye GOP
- The Bean Walker
- Caffeinated Thoughts
- The Conservative Reader: Iowa
- The Iowa Republican
Journalists' blogs and research
- 24-Hour Dorman
- Cedar Rapids Gazette government page
- Iowa Fiscal Partnership
- Iowa Policy Project
- Iowa Politics Insider
- Iowa Watchdog.org
- On Brief: Iowa's Appellate Blog
- On the Campaign Trail with Ed Tibbetts
- Politically Speaking
- Price of Politics, etc.
- O.Kay Henderson at Radio Iowa
Iowa Democrats
- Dave Loebsack (IA-02)
- Iowa Democratic Party
- Iowa House Democrats
- Iowa Senate Democrats

Powered by: SoapBlox