[Bleeding Heartland Logo]

About
Bleeding Heartland is a community blog about Iowa politics: campaigns and elections, state government, social and environmental issues. Bleeding Heartland also weighs in on presidential policies and campaigns, federal legislation and what the Iowans in Congress are up to. Join our community, post your thoughts as comments or diaries, help keep our leaders honest and hold them accountable.
Author
- desmoinesdem
Highlights
- Iowa 2012 election coverage
- Who's who in the Iowa House for 2013
- Who's who in the Iowa Senate for 2013
- Iowa wildflowers
2014 Election Coverage
- Absentee ballot numbers
- IA-Sen
- IA-Gov
- IA-01
- IA-02
- IA-03
- IA-04
- Secretary of Agriculture
- Secretary of State
- State Auditor
- Iowa Senate overview
- Iowa House overview
- Senate district 5
- Senate district 7
- Senate district 9
- Senate district 13
- Senate district 15
- Senate district 17
- Senate district 27
- Senate district 29
- Senate district 39
- Senate district 41
- Senate district 47
- Senate district 49
- House district 8
- House district 25
- House district 28
- House district 33 (2013)
- House district 40
- House district 51
- House district 60
- House district 65
- House district 68
- House district 73
- House district 91
- House district 92
- House district 95
- House district 99
Search




Advanced Search


Paid Advertising


Bleeding Heartland
It's what plants crave.

Iowa Senate ad watch: Water bottles (really)

by: desmoinesdem

Thu Oct 25, 2012 at 14:10:00 PM CDT


In a surprising turn of events, Republican challengers are putting an obscure vote on water bottles at the center of their attacks on Iowa Senate Democrats. Follow me after the jump for background on this year's equivalent to the non-existent "heated sidewalks" of 2010.
desmoinesdem :: Iowa Senate ad watch: Water bottles (really)
Some version of the water bottles attack has appeared in radio and/or television commercials against Democratic Senators Mary Jo Wilhelm (SD-26) and Tom Courtney (SD-44), print advertising against Jeff Danielson (SD-30), and direct mail targeting Senate Majority Leader Mike Gronstal (SD-08), Brian Schoenjahn (SD-32), and Steve Sodders (SD-36).

Here's the gist of the Republican message: store owners across Iowa report that some people are abusing food assistance benefits, buying large bottles of water, dumping out the water in the parking lot, and walking right back inside to collect the $7.50 bottle refund. The worst part is that this behavior is completely legal. [Insert Republican Senate candidate's name] would vote for a law to stop this abuse. But [insert Democratic state senator's name] failed to vote against letting people on food stamps take water bottles and return them right away to collect the deposit.

The first wave of ads featuring this attack left some people scratching their heads. What are they talking about?

As with the bogus heated sidewalk claim, this charge stems from a Republican amendment that would have had no real impact, even if Democrats had approved it.

Bottle deposit returns came up in May 2011, when the Iowa Senate debated the health and human services appropriations bill for fiscal year 2012 (House File 649). Republican Senators Merlin Bartz and Brad Zaun proposed the following amendment (excerpt):

The department [of Human Services] shall submit a request to the United States department of agriculture for authorization for a waiver, pilot project, or other approach for restricting the use of food assistance benefits, as administered by the state under the federal supplemental nutrition assistance program, for both of the following: food items that are taxable and the deposit portion of the cost of food items sold in a container that is subject to a deposit.

The Senate rejected the Bartz/Zaun amendment S-3337 on a party line vote (pdf). Later the same day, the Senate approved the health and human services budget bill on a party-line vote.

Senate Democratic caucus research staff provided the following background information to Bleeding Heartland. In 2008, the Iowa Department of Human Services had requested a waiver to stop the use of food assistance benefits to purchase bottle deposits. The federal Food and Nutrition Service denied that request, saying the government was focused on implementing "stricter penalties for people proven guilty of abusing the bottle deposit policy." At the end of this post I've enclosed a letter from the Iowa Department of Human Services confirming those events.

Iowa has not pursued a similar waiver since 2008 because there is "no indication [federal officials] will be changing their opinion on this issue." So, even if the Senate had approved the Bartz/Zaun amendment, Iowans receiving federal food assistance would still be able to buy big bottles of water.

In recent years, the U.S. Department of Agriculture has stepped up its enforcement of rules against the improper use of the supplemental nutrition assistance program. Iowa store owners or anyone else who knows about the abuse of food assistance benefits can call this toll-free fraud hotline: 1-800-831-1394.

I have no idea whether this line of attack will turn a significant number of voters against Senate incumbents. Ever since Ronald Reagan successfully demonized "welfare queens," Republicans have tried to exploit anger toward people who abuse public assistance programs. A GOP-controlled Senate wouldn't be able to change federal policy on buying bottle deposits, but why let reality get in the way of a campaign talking point?

DHS letter on water bottles, Iowa Department of Human Services official explains policy on restricting use of food assistance benefits for bottled water

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
Tweet This!

Courtney (4.00 / 1)
People do these gotcha votes all of the time, the smart thing to do is just vote for the baloney and then hope reasonable people do their research and don't hold the vote against you.  

I've seen the ads against Tom Courtney because of the overlap in our media markets, I don't think they will change many votes.  


Courtney shouldn't have any problems (0.00 / 0)
but some of the other races could be decided by a handful of votes.

Invite other Iowa political junkies to join us at Bleeding Heartland.

[ Parent ]
Since you mention Senator BZ (4.00 / 1)
Can a response here in defense of the bill and of the campaign targeted advertising from you-know-who be far behind?

I don't know who the "you know who" is you are talking about.... (4.00 / 3)
...but good thing you didn't bring up Staci Apple or Laura Sands or Roger Jepsen or I would of gone off!  (winks)

[ Parent ]
Aahh, inter-party warm fuzzies (0.00 / 0)
This close to election day is nice.

[ Parent ]
re: Jerry Behn (4.00 / 1)
He has been running those ads with his personal signature at the end of the commercial. Which is really odd when you consider that his quality opponent is running for the Senate for the first time and the incumbant is Behn.

With all his travels this year as Minority Leader he might be putting his face out there just to make up for his bad ground game this year.


in some of the Iowa House races (0.00 / 0)
Rs are trying to pin the I-JOBS vote on Democratic candidates who weren't even in the legislature. Typical.

Why Behn hasn't raised more money for his Senate candidates is beyond me.

Invite other Iowa political junkies to join us at Bleeding Heartland.


[ Parent ]
Menu

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?


Iowa Liberal Blogs
- Ames Progressive
- Blog For Iowa
- Essential Estrogen
- Iowa .Gif-t Shop
- Iowa Independent (archive)
- Iowa Policy Points
- Iowans for a Future That Doesn't Suck
- John Deeth
Iowa Conservative Blogs
- Hawkeye GOP
- The Bean Walker
- Caffeinated Thoughts
- The Conservative Reader: Iowa
- The Iowa Republican
Journalists' blogs and research
- 24-Hour Dorman
- Cedar Rapids Gazette government page
- Iowa Fiscal Partnership
- Iowa Policy Project
- Iowa Politics Insider
- Iowa Watchdog.org
- On Brief: Iowa's Appellate Blog
- On the Campaign Trail with Ed Tibbetts
- Newton Independent (Peter Hussmann)
- Politically Speaking
- Price of Politics, etc.
- O.Kay Henderson at Radio Iowa
Iowa Democrats
- Tom Harkin (U.S. Senator)
- Bruce Braley (IA-01)
- Dave Loebsack (IA-02)
- Iowa Democratic Party
- Iowa House Democrats
- Iowa Senate Democrats
Statistics


 
Powered by: SoapBlox