[Bleeding Heartland Logo]

About
Bleeding Heartland is a community blog about Iowa politics: campaigns and elections, state government, social and environmental issues. Bleeding Heartland also weighs in on presidential policies and campaigns, federal legislation and what the Iowans in Congress are up to. Join our community, post your thoughts as comments or diaries, help keep our leaders honest and hold them accountable.
Author
- desmoinesdem
Highlights
- Iowa 2012 election coverage
- Who's who in the Iowa House for 2013
- Who's who in the Iowa Senate for 2013
- Iowa wildflowers
2014 Election Coverage
- Absentee ballot numbers
- IA-Sen
- IA-Gov
- IA-01
- IA-02
- IA-03
- IA-04
- Secretary of Agriculture
- Secretary of State
- State Auditor
- Iowa Senate overview
- Iowa House overview
- Senate district 5
- Senate district 7
- Senate district 9
- Senate district 13
- Senate district 15
- Senate district 17
- Senate district 27
- Senate district 29
- Senate district 39
- Senate district 41
- Senate district 47
- Senate district 49
- House district 8
- House district 25
- House district 28
- House district 33 (2013)
- House district 40
- House district 51
- House district 60
- House district 65
- House district 68
- House district 73
- House district 91
- House district 92
- House district 95
- House district 99
Search




Advanced Search


Paid Advertising


Bleeding Heartland
It's what plants crave.

Wanted: Republicans who understand judicial review

by: desmoinesdem

Tue Apr 14, 2009 at 17:30:25 PM CDT


Is there any way to arrange a remedial civics class for prominent Iowa Republicans? Here's Bob Vander Plaats on Monday:

"If I have the opportunity to serve as your next governor," Bob Vander Plaats told a crowd of about 350 people at a rally, "and if no leadership has been taken to that point, on my first day of office I will issue an executive order that puts a stay on same-sex marriages until the people of Iowa vote, and when we vote we can affirm and amend the Constitution."

Another highlight from the same rally:

Co-founder of Everyday America, Bill Salier, told the crowd that state lawmakers need to thank the Supreme Court justices for their opinion but say it's merely opinion and the law is still on the books.

Salier said: "(Lawmakers) can face down the court and say, 'We passed DOMA, the Defense of Marriage Act. You claim that it is stricken. And yet unless some magic eraser came down from the sky, it's still in code.'"

Then there's Republican State Representative Chris Rants, who is trying to amend the tax reform bill so that marriage would be defined as between a man and a woman. Rants failed last week to replace a huge health care bill with an amendment to ban same-sex marriage.

Meanwhile, Republican State Senator Merlin Bartz is pushing an amendment that would allow county recorders not to issue marriage licenses.

This daughter of a Rockefeller Republican is shaking her head and has a few more things to say after the jump.

desmoinesdem :: Wanted: Republicans who understand judicial review
Are there any Republicans left who understand the following?

1. The Constitution protects citizens' rights and freedoms.

2. The legislature makes laws, but those laws cannot infringe on rights protected by the Constitution.

3. The governor can issue executive orders, but those orders cannot infringe on rights protected by the Constitution.

4. When people disagree over whether a law or executive order violates the Constitution, the dispute is settled in courts.

If marriage equality is such an emotional issue that it short-circuits the conservative brain, let's put it in the context of a law many Republicans dislike: Iowa's smoking ban.

Some bar and restaurant owners believe the law adopted last year went too far in restricting their property rights, and they have challenged it in the courts. The smoking ban remains in effect pending the court challenge, just as the six couples who were plaintiffs in Varnum v Brien were unable to be married while their lawsuit was working its way through the judicial system.

I don't give the smoking ban opponents much chance of winning their lawsuit, but if the courts rule this law unconstitutional, then the law will be invalid and unenforceable. The will of the people, as expressed through the legislature, cannot supersede the constitution.

Drake University Law Professor Mark Kende points out that neither what Vander Plaats and Salier are advocating nor the latest amendment Rants is proposing pass constitutional muster.

Will any senior Republicans dare to state the obvious: that amending Iowa's Constitution is the only way to get around the Iowa Supreme Court's ruling in Varnum v Brien?

Are Republicans like Vander Plaats and Salier ignorant about how our system works, or are they just pandering to the conservative base?

Share your thoughts in this thread.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
Tweet This!

My Thoughts??? (4.00 / 1)
Well, I remember a woman I knew coming from a Republican statehouse race rally and telling me that what I didn't understand about abortion was this...

She told me that there are young women, who only get pregnant so they can get an abortion, and then get tattoos to show how many babies they have sacrificed for Satan.

So tell me, dear daughter of a Rockefeller Republican, if we can't keep these nutjobs out of your womb, what chance do we have of keeping them out of people's bedrooms?


My Thoughts??? (0.00 / 0)
Well, I remember a woman I knew coming from a Republican statehouse race rally and telling me that what I didn't understand about abortion was this...

She told me that there are young women, who only get pregnant so they can get an abortion, and then get tattoos to show how many babies they have sacrificed for Satan.

So tell me, dear daughter of a Rockefeller Republican, if we can't keep these nutjobs out of your womb, what chance do we have of keeping them out of people's bedrooms?


Huh? Oops? Sorry... (0.00 / 0)
How the heck did that happen?  Hmmmm, maybe I shouldn't have mentioned the name of the Dark One???

[ Parent ]
that's happened to me before (4.00 / 1)
For some reason it happens on soapblox (the system that runs this blog) from time to time. No biggie!

Invite other Iowa political junkies to join us at Bleeding Heartland.

[ Parent ]
Oh, so just a minor technical glitch? (0.00 / 0)
Rats.  I liked my theory a lot better.

[ Parent ]
I don't know, but... (4.00 / 2)
from what I heard when passing by the tea party that took place in front of the statehouse on Saturday afternoon, phrases like "take back our country," "return to founding principles," and ""great Americans" are perfectly suitable replacements for law and logic in the minds of many of our state's most vocal conservatives.  Different issue, I know, but I think many of the same folks probably showed up for the anti-marriage rights protest held there yesterday.  Honestly, even after listening to them list their nine founding principles, I have no idea what the group who sponsored the protest stands for.
(Had family in town and were taking in the Historical Building and the capitol building...I felt a bit like an industrial spy!)

These Republicans have seen Bush and Cheney disregard laws, so why can't they? (4.00 / 2)


Thoughts (4.00 / 1)
Democrats need to repeatedly remind Republicans like Rants that this country was founded on the priciples of the "rule of law" and a "free and independent judiciary". The question for them is whether they still believe in our founding priciples. If not, they are advocating revolution. That is treasonous.

Menu

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?


Iowa Liberal Blogs
- Ames Progressive
- Blog For Iowa
- Essential Estrogen
- Iowa .Gif-t Shop
- Iowa Independent (archive)
- Iowa Policy Points
- Iowans for a Future That Doesn't Suck
- John Deeth
Iowa Conservative Blogs
- Hawkeye GOP
- The Bean Walker
- Caffeinated Thoughts
- The Conservative Reader: Iowa
- The Iowa Republican
Journalists' blogs and research
- 24-Hour Dorman
- Cedar Rapids Gazette government page
- Iowa Fiscal Partnership
- Iowa Policy Project
- Iowa Politics Insider
- Iowa Watchdog.org
- On Brief: Iowa's Appellate Blog
- On the Campaign Trail with Ed Tibbetts
- Newton Independent (Peter Hussmann)
- Politically Speaking
- Price of Politics, etc.
- O.Kay Henderson at Radio Iowa
Iowa Democrats
- Tom Harkin (U.S. Senator)
- Bruce Braley (IA-01)
- Dave Loebsack (IA-02)
- Iowa Democratic Party
- Iowa House Democrats
- Iowa Senate Democrats
Statistics


 
Powered by: SoapBlox