Tea Party movement can't grasp meaning of "socialism"

So the North Iowa Tea Party covered up their Mason City billboard that juxtaposed pictures of Adolf Hitler (“National Socialism”), Barack Obama (“Democrat Socialism”) and Vladimir Lenin (“Marxist Socialism”) over the slogan, “Radical leaders prey on the fearful & naive.” (Here’s a photo.) Activists in statewide tea party circles repudiated the billboard. Ryan Rhodes, chairman of the Iowa Tea Party movement, wants fellow travelers to educate the public about freedom and U.S. history. Rhodes’ problem was the Hitler imagery, not the underlying message that we’re headed toward socialism.

I know I’m supposed to be outraged that right-wingers would compare Obama to Hitler, but I’m too stunned that anyone paying attention to the news could view Obama as “socialist.” I got a window onto the tea party mindset from Bob Johnson, one of the Mason City billboard’s creators. For your weekly dose of unintentional comedy, I recommend Jennifer Jacobs’ interview with Johnson on the Des Moines Register blog. Among his insights:

“It was absolutely not the aim to just create controversy. Nobody’s more surprised about the thing than I am,” Johnson said. “This billboard was misunderstood. I’m not going to say it was a mistake.” […]

“We had some hesitations about it,” Johnson said, “but for those that understand it, it’s just such a powerful billboard, so we said screw it and go ahead with it.” […]

“When we put that Hitler up there, it just totally overwhelmed everything on the billboard,” Johnson said. “That’s the one thing that just destroyed the whole concept we did not realize the power Hitler still has, the emotion.” […]

“When you want to compare the present administration to Hitler, Hitler took over the banks. Gee, what’s this administration doing? Hitler took over the health care. Gee. Hitler took over the transportation and what’s this administration doing? If that wasn’t a direct comparison to socialism, I don’t know what is.”

Let’s consider the so-called government takeover of health care, a major area of concern for the tea partiers. Under socialized medicine (as exists in real socialist countries), the government employs all the doctors and runs all the clinics and hospitals. Under single-payer health care (as exists in Canada), the government pays for medical care, but most doctors and medical institutions are privately operated.

In contrast, Obama had his top aides cut deals with health industry interests, working closely with the most corporate-friendly Congressional  committee drafting a health reform bill. The key staffer charged with writing that committee’s bill, Liz Fowler, came straight from one of the largest health insurance companies. Obama broke many significant campaign promises on health care so as not to tread on corporate interests. As a result, key industries got virtually everything they wanted from the bill that passed. Private health insurance companies are now guaranteed millions of new customers in the coming years, with no new competition from government-run entities. Completing the circle, Fowler is now working for the Obama administration to help implement the health reform law.

Rest assured, no corporate CEO in America is lying awake at night worried about “socialist” health care the way Johnson says he worried people might bomb his house because they didn’t like his billboard.

Most of the Obama administration’s economic team came straight from the Wall Street culture, and the president hasn’t tried to “take over” or even break up major financial institutions.

I have no idea what Johnson is talking about when he suggests the Obama administration has been taking over the transportation sector.

Anyone who has such a skewed view of this corporate-friendly administration could gain perspective from spending a few weeks in a socialist country.

  • Sometimes, I do enjoy watching Glenn Beck...

    Those of us who do understand the history of the “alphabet of the left” know that there are vast differences between the red, black, and green “vanguard” movements.  

    It tickles me to see Beck paint the left with a broad brush, calling everyone on the so-called left “socialist” or “communist”.  It shows what a truly ignorant fool he is.  Hopefully this whole billboard debacle is a demonstration of how fragmented the Tea Party folks are, and that there is no danger of a larger populist movement coming out of all this.  

    But chillingly, there is a HUGE amount of disinformation being spread by that man, Glenn Beck.  He claims to have THE handbook of the socialist revolution of the left, apparently written by one small faction, that I, a devout anarchist and pretty seriously active member of the Peace Movement, have never even heard of.  

    Kind of reminds me of that wonderful book “Protocols of the Elders of Zion”, you know, the one that justified the pogroms and genocide of the previous century?

  • Socialism

    I get so tired of people confusing socialism with faschism.  And then that White Neonazi in Arizona is assisting in the rounding up of the illegal aliens, and they use “The Socialist Party.”  they are in no way Socialists.  Faschists, probably.  My favorite Senator is a Socialist, Sen.  Sanders.  There is a huge difference between the two.  People are equating Socialism with Stalin, Hitler, Mao, etc.  They are throwing them all in the same bag.  I wish there were some way to educate the American Public.  And they would listen.  (big AND).

You need to signin or signup to post a comment.