Democrats have a patriotism perception problem

Joe Stutler is an Army veteran and member of the Iowa Democratic Veterans’ Caucus. -promoted by desmoinesdem

Democrats have a patriotism perception problem…one with a simple solution.

Let’s start by acknowledging the elephant in the room. Literally. The GOP (symbol: you guessed it, the pestiferous pachyderm) owns the idea of “patriotism,” that deep pride in and love of country that is such an emotional driver for many. And drive it does…straight to the polls.

Nathaniel Rakich and Dhrumil Mehta reported on this phenomenon in early July at, and the numbers are stunning even to someone who has been warning of this problem for more than a decade. In their piece “We’re Divided On Patriotism Too,” they wrote,

Overall, the survey found that 76 percent of Americans consider themselves “very” or “somewhat” patriotic. But between Republicans and Democrats, there were pretty big differences: A whopping 97 percent of Republicans placed themselves in the “very” or “somewhat” categories, compared with 71 percent of Democrats. That’s a gap of 26 percentage points. Even more starkly, 72 percent of Republicans consider themselves to be “very” patriotic (the highest level of patriotism), compared with 29 percent of Democrats — a 43-point gap.

We might ask, is there really a problem, or is this just a “perception” thing? Are Republicans really more patriotic than Democrats? The answer is perception is reality, so yes, we do have a problem. Remember, these numbers are based on what self-identified Republicans and Democrats say about themselves, not their perceptions of each other!

One key factor of the patriotism perception problem is that Republicans tend to be more hawkish, and consequently more connected with the military. While Democrats are generally better on the issues that impact our troops and veterans, the GOP has done far better on messaging, and they have for years. Republicans have been consistent and noisy about supporting the troops and caring for our vets, even though their party in reality is far more supportive of defense contractors than of those who risk their lives for our freedoms.

At virtually every event, every meeting, the GOP makes sure the symbolism is there, loud and proud, be it “Veterans for…” signs or mentions in speeches or having clearly-identifiable vets in their back bleachers and crowd shots. For Republicans, it’s automatic. With the Democrats, on the other hand, troops and vets appear to be an afterthought, if we’re thought of at all.

What does this mean for Democratic candidates? For one thing, it means you’re starting on the down-side of a 26- to 43-point gap on the patriotism issue. Even at the low end, that’s a big gap. Chances are, while it may not be the key issue for many voters, it can skew their perceptions of you overall.

There is a solution to this problem, and it’s easy and cheap: Show you care. That’s it.

Simple indeed…so what does that entail? Put a Military/Veterans section in your issues package. It doesn’t have to be your primary issue, just make clear you recognize the topic is important enough to be included. Be sure to invite and acknowledge service members and veterans to your events and meetings. Have a military/veterans adviser for your campaign. If you are a veteran, say so. If you are the spouse, child, grandchild, or parent of active duty military or veterans, say so with pride. Hold press conferences, forums, or roundtables where military and veterans are a focus, or where related issues are discussed.

These basic actions will show in a public way that you are indeed patriotic, at least as far as perception goes. They will also make you better informed about the military and veterans, so you can speak to related subjects when questioned, for example in debates. They will give your supporters the resources they need to promote you to their peers and others. They will help show independents and Republicans that Democrats are good on issues that matter to them.

Think of taking these steps as getting an inoculation. It doesn’t take much effort, and can help immunize you against the right-wing attacks on our supposed lack of patriotism.

Top image: Iowa Democratic Veterans’ Caucus Color Guard at the Iowa Democratic Party’s Jefferson-Jackson Dinner in October 2015.

Maintenance Notice - As of November 14, 2023 we are still seeing issues with replying to comments...Thanks for your patience, this will be restored.

  • All of which makes the irony

    of Republicans being perfectly OK

    with the ConFraudUS that transpired between the Trump campaign

    and the Russians in the 2016 election, and that is still

    ongoing today — so deep, so broad, so rich, and so tragic an


    Ten years ago I had thought and said to a couple of people that

    the GOP will within a few more election cycles understand that

    the national demographics make their prospects for winning a

    “fair fight” presidential election so grim that they’ll come to

    adopt Putin-style poisonings and mysterious accidents of their


    Not necessary, as it turned out. Just let one of our decades

    long criminals employ Mr. Putin to help steal a party and an

    election and slap a Republican MAGA face on it, and they’re all

    good with it. USA! USA! USA!

    When I was a young adult I thought it was odd to observe that

    the party most closely associated with patriotism, even back

    then, sure did seem to have the greater number of individuals

    willing to employ more Machiavellian and otherwise similarly

    distasteful tactics, all the while decrying the “Communist

    menace” abroad. But they can’t help it. It is encoded in

    their DNA. Those without that encoding may gravitate to the

    Democratic party, but may more likely suck at politics.

    There is a line in the book “All The Kremlin’s Men” uttered by

    one of those men about how remarkably “flexible” one’s ethics

    and allegiances can be in the pursuit of power. There are more

    than a few Republicans that can certainly relate to that

    sentiment today.

  • Confused?

    You are mixing up love of country with love of militarism. “Patriotism” has come to mean militarism. There is no evidence that Democrats love their hometowns, their national forests, their civil liberties, i.e, their country, any less than Republicans. When Dems say they are not patriotic, they mean they won’t automatically back a military solution to a foreign affairs problem the way John McCain and other Republicans always, always do.

    • Confused?? Not at all....

      ….See, many of us understand the meanings of the words we use. We understand the difference between militarism, jingoism, and patriotism. We know that military solutions are not always the best solution, but sometimes they are the necessary solution.
      But then, I’m going off of my own years of experience with this issue, and what the statistics indicate.

  • Interesting

    I think Joe Stutler’s suggestions are interesting and deserve consideration. I appreciate his piece appearing on BH.

  • Patriotism Perception

    This actually is a good idea. Democrats tend to focus more on veterans AFTER they come back and they could stand to make that more obvious.
    Yes, I think they should have veteran groups at their rallies, and for that matter in some ads.