We’re upset about Dr. Roberts' detention—for good reason

Jenny Turner is a public school mom and a school speech therapist. She lives in West Des Moines.

It might be prudent to wait for all the facts before writing an opinion piece on ICE detaining Dr. Ian Roberts, the superintendent of Des Moines Public Schools. It is true that there is a lot we don’t know. Which leads me to the central question: why don’t we know?

Dr. Roberts has allegedly had a removal order for nearly a year and a half. Why did the district not know about this? Why was Dr. Roberts arrested suddenly, in the most dramatic fashion, for what amounts to late paperwork (if true)? Why was no thought put into the effect this would have on the community and the kids? Why was it not done mindfully to minimize the impact?

Many of us are highly skeptical of the official story. We are doing our own investigative journalism on social media, because we don’t know if he was a citizen, or if he lied, or if the removal order was for another person with the same name.

It doesn’t add up or make sense. Why would you arrest a community leader, whom hundreds of kids look up to, without getting that figured out and clearly communicated?

ICE has not been a trustworthy agency at all. Slamming distraught women to the ground, waiting for the lunch rush to violently arrest someone at a public grocery store, losing track of hundreds of people, detaining citizens, admitting to journalists that they’re looking for people of color, calling people “animals,” making up crimes to cover up improper deportation of legal residents to torture facilities abroad, publicly displaying complete lack of weapons training. Why should we believe them now?

ICE is supposed to be a public agency of public servants that serves the people. We the people deserve transparency and competence. We deserve an agency that works for us.

We also deserve politicians who work for us. We don’t deserve statements like those on offer from U.S. Representatives Ashley Hinson and Randy Feenstra, or Governor Kim Reynolds, which showed 100 percent support for the Trump administration with 0 percent work to find out what is happening or support the community. They are obviously working for political points, not us.

We don’t deserve for the Des Moines Public Schools to be smeared with no information about what happened, even though school districts in four other states and Washington, D.C. also vetted Dr. Roberts. The Des Moines School Board is doing an excellent job in my opinion of providing the information they have, reassuring the community, and being cautious to be as accurate as possible with limited information.

We don’t deserve statements from politicians crafted carefully with elections in mind, disregarding our pain and shock. We may not have the facts, but it is a fact that people are rightfully upset. We don’t deserve silence either—if you’re in politics you should care about the people.

Regardless of where the facts of this case end up, a lot of people gave the game away on this one. We need people in government who have the guts to care about people and the truth. Here I have to praise Iowa City—maybe the “People’s Republic of Iowa City” isn’t such a pejorative.

To the people of the Des Moines area, Iowa, and the rest of the U.S., I would say don’t settle for less than government of the people, by the people, and for the people. That government must find out and tell us the facts in Dr. Roberts’ case and take appropriate, not theatrical, action.

About the Author(s)

Jenny Turner

  • Homan, Miller, and company

    have been upfront that they are trying to sow as much fear as they can by these gestapo tactics.
    This is what is being celebrated by our Repug leaders and for some reason Rod Sand is choosing to identify with law enforcement in reference to his take on this awful an ICE raid, while ICE is openly running a racial profiling ethic cleansing scheme, assaulting people (while falsely charging others,including elected Dems, with assaulting them) on the streets and in their homes, shooting reporters (often in the face/head). We don’t need “conversations” about this secret state police mob (or now apparently top military brass being directed to take part on the “war” against Blue cities/states) we need active and principled resistance like Gov Pritzker is offering.

  • Pain ?

    If the Des Moines school,district would have verified his eligibility in the first place, you can toast the buck onto a hiring agency you decided to use! Verify yourself and run your OWN school background check !!! Many ,many school districts do such.

    He handed you 2 forms of ID ? That doesn’t mean they are legit without a back ground check. He was registered to vote in Maryland, how is that legal and possible? That needs to be explained .

    Trying to pass this off on the federal govt or a hiring agency ? Whoa . Good luck with that .

  • Waiting for more

    I had three main thoughts when I first heard of the arrest. In no particular order: 1) What does this mean for the bond measure that will be before voters in November? How integral was Dr. Roberts’ vision for that proposed future of Des Moines schools? 2) Dr. Roberts was not hiding over the past two years, or even the past eight months. When and how did ICE and/or other agencies attempt to detain Dr. Roberts? (I do not know if the dramatic arrest was part of a chain, or was an initial event.) This has meaning for how the government process of removal is being prioritized and managed. 3) Dr. Roberts’ immigration status is a matter for the courts, should they be allowed to act as a free and independent judiciary. His status, in position and in respect, within the community is a testament to the message that immigrants, regardless of their status, have value for our communities and nation. I appreciate Ms. Turner’s intentions, but I found her post to be unproductive in moving the dialogue. I cannot express at this time what might be more productive. To start, I would look at old news reports from throughout his life, including other places where he worked in the United States. Give me a picture of the person and how he became who is. Give me a context of what he means to the future of students in Des Moines. Give me his story in context of what it means for deportations and immigration. Not a small task, but it could have a stronger influence in changing the dialogue from government power to the needs of the people.

  • Outlier21st are you saying his status is the main concern ?

    Are you implying that this guy should have been treated better? How so? They came to do their job , they had the legal authority and he had a removal order. Why did this guy if such the profound man of the Des Moines public school system take off? High speed case? Firearm, a knife and 3,000 dollars in a publicly owned vehicle?

    It seems your more concerned about his status as an educator , versus rule of law? How about him voting in the state of Maryland ? If NOT a US citizen and in the country as stated by an over extended student visa ? That’s another law broken ?

    If you’re worried about the future of the Des Moines public school system , maybe the board will learn to do their own background checks ? As many other schools still do when hiring a firm to find a new administrator .

    What this means for the future of whom? You mean illegals in the United States ? The end result should be what? If your a US citizen and wanted on a warrant just because you did some good in society does that mean your warrant for your arrest should go without taking you in?

    The mere idea that some think illegals are due anything besides the law ? Please. Go try and sneak into Canada and see what happens when you get caught . Will they allow you to stay and be a Canadian citizen? Yes or no? Why?

  • Who are you?

    This is such an important issue that I wish those offering comments here provide names and some info about qualifications or how, if at all, the comment is more than a personal opinion. I don’t have any inside info, and I doubt others have such.

    To dirk from Iowa City, I have no doubt the Republicans see a big wedge possibility in the Roberts situation, based on a claim on favoritism in the hiring process … hence “federal” investigation.

    To “MidwestConservative” You have no evidence that the school board is trying to “pass off” anything. An I-9 form allows a variety (or mix) of documents to verify eligibility. To intimate fault in the employment process, or other shortcomings, is dangerous territory. Roberts has an attorney who is the only contact the district board has with Roberts.You say w/o foundation that “… many other schools still do (their own backgrounder into immigration status) when hiring a firm to find a new administrator.” That is not true.

    To Outlier21. I acknowledge your questions. They will be answered in due time. The question is whether/not he was eligible to work. And, if so, what then? If not, what then? By cancelling his license, the BEE has already traveled down this untested path.

    ME. I have more confidence in the local school board to accept facts, and sift through untruths, and move forward without Dr. Roberts. The major school reform referendum still lies ahead.

  • How Confidence Games Work

    Confidence men or “con artists” as history has labeled them – fool people by building false trust through fabricated credentials and exploiting institutional vulnerabilities. They often use elaborate deceptions and conflicting personal details, relying on victims own blind spots that would normally signal something’s off. These methods succeed by leveraging social norms of trust and urgency, making targets complicit in overlooking red flags until the con unravels. A doctorate from an online university might raise some eyebrows. Conflicting or missing personal and professional details? Reference checks? E-verify results? If this does prove out to be such a situation, the best outcome will be to learn from the situation so it doesn’t happen again.

  • Des Moines school board got what they wanted

    The more and more information comes out on this. It seems the Des Moines school board had exactly the man they wanted. In fact someone would say it almost sounded too good to be true, and we all know what happens the majority of the time when something or someone sounds too good to be true. Guess what they are or that item is too good to be true

    I agree an online doctorate degree that we don’t even know was legit but you’re giving a man over other candidates. The job with an online doctor degree really

    It seems two more schools come out and denied what Ian Roberts said he did. It’s totally false.

    https://www.desmoinesregister.com/story/news/2025/10/01/dmps-superintendent-ian-andre-roberts-did-not-attend-mit-university-says/86454972007/

  • hi Gerald

    not sure why this “To dirk from Iowa City, I have no doubt the Republicans see a big wedge possibility in the Roberts situation, based on a claim on favoritism in the hiring process … hence “federal” investigation.” was addressed to me?
    Sure, as I noted this very public and over the top police action was part of a broader campaign of fear and propaganda, but I think even for Faux News types Roberts is just a minor blip on their radar, look how quickly they moved on from Charlie Kirk as they don’t really care about individuals and need constant new trophies for their audience.

Comments