Classroom lightning is harder to find

Bruce Lear lives in Sioux City and has been connected to Iowa’s public schools for 38 years. He taught for eleven years and represented educators as an Iowa State Education Association regional director for 27 years until retiring. He can be reached at BruceLear2419@gmail.com 

Lately, I’ve been thinking about some of the great times I had teaching high school. I remember those rare times when classroom discussion took on a life of its own. A spark ignited, and the conversation became spontaneous, insightful, and real. When it happened, it was a joyful rush like discovering a $10 bill in a seldom worn pair of pants. 

It was classroom lightning.

My guess is most teachers have experienced a flash of it, and it’s part of what keeps them teaching instead of bailing for a job with less stress and better pay.

After I taught, I represented teachers for 27 years, so I haven’t been gone from public education long enough to romanticize it. The grind of teaching is real including lunch duty, unpaid hours, administrative bureaucracy, multiple extra duties, and people who believe if they attended third grade, they know how to teach it. 

Most of the time my best discussion prompts were met with classroom silence, and indifference. It was exhausting trying to pull thoughts from sophomores who hadn’t bothered to open the book.

But when the lightning struck, it fed my teaching soul. Now, I’m afraid classroom lightning in Iowa is even harder to find than it was 35 years ago when I taught. Teachers today compete with social media, cell phones, impossible classroom numbers, administrators second guessing, and meddling politicians who regard public schools as a political wedge instead of a precious resource needing protection.

It’s harder now than it was then.

It doesn’t matter which party captures all three branches of government, that party falls in love with their own ideas and their unchecked power. That’s what happened in 2017. Bill Dix, Senate Majority Leader at the time, said Republicans were “going to kick the door in.” They did. 

Public-school teachers were flattened by that door.

Republicans silenced teacher voices by gutting Iowa’s 44-year-old public sector bargaining law. They passed laws regulating what can be discussed in classrooms. They banned books they didn’t like from public school libraries. They overhauled Area Education Agencies, diverting some of their funding sources, and they rammed through taxpayer funding for private schools—a “standing appropriation” with no ceiling.

Veteran teachers started looking for the exits and future teachers ran away from the profession. Academic freedom became endangered, and administrators became hyper risk-averse.

Even when I was teaching, I had administrators who fell in love with canned teaching methods they discovered at the latest, greatest conference. We called them “flavors of the month.” To me, they all tasted like vanilla, and students deserved more flavors. Still, in my day, there was some classroom autonomy when you shut the door and tried something that might work. That’s scarce now.

By 1990 when I started representing teachers, classroom independence was crumbling. For example, some principals criticized teachers for not being on the exact unit their lesson plans specified, even when the teacher explained there was a need to re-teach a concept. It was absurd and disheartening.

As we begin a new school year, what can be done to bring back classroom lightning? Voters need to hold politicians more accountable. Please look at their records and ignore their rhetoric. Ask the tough questions, and if the answer doesn’t pass the smell test, run away from supporting them.

Parents can help too. Lotion and gift cards are nice, but if parents want to appreciate teachers, partner with them. Try to attend parent-teacher conferences, make sure your kids get enough sleep, enough to eat, and some time away from cell phones and video games. Try to have them read a little every day, or maybe read to them. It’s hard, but it will help. 

Administrators can help too. Avoid overreaction and second-guessing. Trust the teacher you hired. Listen to each other. Give them some grace. Stop treating parents like customers who are always right. They are sometimes, but not always. 

I recently bought a shirt that says, “Stop blaming teachers.” If we don’t, we’ll have classrooms full of kids, but missing qualified teachers.

About the Author(s)

Bruce Lear

  • Oh Bruce oh Bruce

    Wow Bruce a lot to unpack there. It looks like all the blaming for poor education is Republicans and parents is that what you’re getting at Bruce?

    Have you ever stopped and thought why more and more parents are choosing homeschooling versus public education ?

    have you ever stopped to think why more homeschooling take places and why people are leaving public education versus private schools where you don’t have very much homeschooling at all taking place ?they love their private schools.

    There’s a fine line between a public education and indoctrinating children into thinking certain things and sadly you wonder why more people choose to go home for their school when what’s being taught in a lot of public schools across the nation ? Teachings that are totally irrelevant to an education of a child.

    And if you think for a hot second that you don’t have teachers that after teaching for 12-20 years haven’t checked out you’re sadly mistaken. I have sat on a school board myself and saw teachers using the same lesson plans that were outdated seven,10,12 years past what the times were..

    Bargaining agreements ? hence another joke again I sat on a school board when it came time to collective bargaining, and those same teachers that were using outdated lesson plans , they were the ones crying for a raise at the expense of young energetic teachers losing their jobs. You’re to be paid on performance not tenor !

    So for you , who I’m sure did your share of indoctrinating on the liberal causes while you were a high school teacher, and I believe in charge of the school paper, correct Bruce ?

    to write the woes me that you have written here and effectively blame parents and Republicans for the public school system why don’t you go look at large cities like Kansas City, Missouri St. Louis, Missouri Des Moines school Many others across many states that are run primarily by Democrats that I’ve done nothing for education in decades, and some of those schools have become unaccredited that wasn’t because of Republicans nor was it lack of taxpayer money as the schools have massive budgets yet still testing scores are dismal.

    I can tell you if public schools continue to take a woke ideology you’re going to have far more homeschooling than you think.

    And maybe more people should find out what the NEA’s last conference just recently was talking about ? that’s not about education that we’re coming out of their mouth ,best read up on it Bruce

  • Yes Bruce we need a revival of local politics

    as is discussed in this podcast (https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/201-use-it-or-lose-it/id1080145136?i=1000716665751) .

    Has anyone heard yet if Robs Sand wants to end vouchers or if he just wants them to be more accountable for the public money they receive?

  • I am sure Bruce

    can speak for himself but as a retired teacher myself, who spent years hoping for that lightning to occur and rejoicing when it did, MidwestCon is way off base. I would like to know of specific schools teaching the ‘woke ideologies’ that he refers to. I would also like to know specific examples of what he considers woke. I taught A Raisin in the Sun for years. Can you point out what is woke there? If I mentioned the racism the Younger family experienced would that be woke? If, when teaching Antigone, I pointed out her dilemma of deciding to follow God’s law over the laws of government, would that be indoctrinating or would that not be because it takes the side of the evangelicals who feel the Bible should be guiding our educational choices? I taught To Kill a Mockingbird. Should I have pointed out that Bob Ewell was expressing his first amendment rights when he called a Black man a “nigger”?
    Finally, you should do some proofreading before you try to tell people that you know how to educate better than experts.

  • hi bodacious

    appreciate yer fighting spirit but feeding trolls is generally counterproductive

  • Dear Midwestconservative

    I think you fall under the category of attending third grade and deciding you know how to teach it. You don’t. I’m deeply sorry you served on a school board since you have such disdain for public schools.

    Most collective bargaining agreements were voluntary, so the board of directors agreed to a settlement. It was collective problem solving. That was destroyed in 2017.

    I did indoctrinate kids. I preached reading literature and economy of expression in writing. I preached deadlines and accuracy. I talked about listening and courtesy.

    I certainly do blame Republicans for using public schools as a political wedge. It’s shameful and counterproductive for Iowa. It has caused the current teacher shortage.

    Keep reading and I will keep making you mad.

  • Not sorry

    I am guilty of engaging trolls and will avoid doing so in the future. Thanks for the advice

  • Dear Bruce and others

    I Sat on an Iowa board in 2003 , then moved from Iowa the following year I was born and raised there. Education prowess? My wife has been in education for 34 years now, trust me she’s not a typical NEA lemming. Did you watch and listen Bruce to the latest NEA convention on your tube ? Listen to her and see how that voice will play in the vast majority of the states.

    These words and actions is a great poster child for why we will see more private schools and vouchers in the future, our local Catholic school has 100% math proficiency at the 10 th grade level. Wonder why? 90% of the alumni is on the honor roll. These private schools teach the basics and not go into the weeds like many public schools have done , no teachers unions or union heads wanting more and more , while the test scores continue to fail our children . It’s not all teachers fault , lots have to do with parents, school boards and social economics, but education in the last 20 years accross the country isn’t what it once was .

    Blaming Republicans for making public education a voting issue? Please 🤦‍♂️ woke agenda and people lie terry mccauliff telling parents shut up and let the teachers do there jobs , your opinions matter little, is what gave the state of Virginia a republican governor once again.

    Again my wife has dedicated her life to public education in various rolls, classroom teacher , principle and head of special education coordinator. Her values are always about the kids education , not politics or woke ideals , trust me I hear plenty of how staff talks plenty about politics . Her focus is always student based , trying to give a child the best education she can , in dealing with all the other noise and home situations.

    It isn’t dollars that will fix public education , that has been proven for decades! as we watch test scores and attendance rates plummet .

  • bodacious

    I salute you and am going to try to follow your good example, though it’s very clear today, per a different post, that it won’t be easy.

Comments