Thoughts about the debate in Iowa's third Congressional district

Gerald Ott of Ankeny was a high school English teacher and for 30 years a school improvement consultant for the Iowa State Education Association. This post first appeared on Substack.

On October 27, I watched the debate between Democratic challenger Sarah Trone Garriott and Republican incumbent Zach Nunn, who are competing to represent Iowa’s third Congressional District. 

Moderators Amanda Rooker and Jodi Long, both journalists at KCCI-TV, acquitted themselves as the professionals they are. In fact, their skills rival any team of moderators the networks might assign for a presidential debate, so congratulations to Amanda and Jodi. Job well done. 

If I have a bone to pick, it might be that centering the debate on the participants’ past voting records was of little importance to me. Nunn sits in the majority party in the U.S. House of Representatives, and Trone Garriott is from the minority party in the state Senate where Republicans hold a huge majority. Apples and oranges. 

So, discussion of any specific vote—like boys in girls bathrooms—was not persuasive. It is well known that Trone Garriott’s personal disposition is to protect and defend minorities from the bigotry of the majority. Republicans like Nunn do not recognize the legitimacy of LBGTQ individuals, especially transgender people. Nunn is on record supporting numerous bills to deny human rights and dignity to LBGTQ people.

A new ad says Trone Garriott supports “gender fluidity,” which means she’s okay with a person telling her they feel uncomfortable with the gender assigned by their genitalia. I can imagine a person baring their soul to her. Hard to imagine a constituent having a similar conversation with Nunn, who must think “gender dysphoria” is a fake malady.

As with her Democratic colleagues, Trone Garriott’s concern is for the one transgender girl, her well-being, her success in school—and her future prospects in an often hostile environment. And that she be included in a school’s academic, social, and extra-curricular activities on the same basis as her cisgender classmates.

Feeling unwelcome, being isolated, badgered or bullied, outed without permission can lead to gender dysphoria, a medical condition. On October 21, the U.S. Supreme Court refused to allow the Trump administration to immediately enforce new medical restrictions for transgender people in federal prisons.

U.S. District Judge Royce Lamberth ordered treatments to continue and pointed out that untreated gender dysphoria can cause severe side effects like depression, anxiety, and suicidal thoughts.

Nunn’s ads go on to make obscene claims about Trone Garriott’s positions on sex change and drug-related therapies. She is opposed, adamantly so. The state legislature has no business intervening with children’s care. That’s the bailiwick of parents and qualified medical personnel.

As do many other Democrats, she wants the sports-participation questions taken out of the heavy hands of state legislatures. Every sport is different. Michigan, for example, uses a special panel to decide these questions on a case-by-case basis.

In the state Senate, Trone Garriott supported a bill to add provisions to Iowa’s pre-existing mandate for sex education in public schools. The bill would add age-appropriate instruction by learning the names of body parts, recognizing and reporting abuse, and showing empathy for human differences in our huge, diverse society. The Republicans nixed the bill, of course, and Nunn ridiculed her for her audacious support of all children.

In this debate, time spent debating these particular issues was time wasted. 

Imagine a mobile suspended above a baby’s crib. Every real issue drops from the top of the mobile like the tentacles of an octopus. For Republicans the center of the mobile is President Donald Trump. To keep Trump suspended, Nunn and his GOP colleagues must accede to his wars, tariffs, abandonment of allies in favor of enemies, abuse of immigrants, ballrooms, extortions, vengeances, bigotry, and so on, to every cruel, inane, or insane act without whimper. 

So, this election is the most important of my lifetime. For whatever reason, the U.S. has fallen under the grip of the most corrupt, vengeful, kleptocratic man in the history of our nation. He has withdrawn from our alliances and supped with our enemy in ways that weaken our nation and harm our peoples. 

Congress has the power to shackle the egregious acts, but Congress has not done so. On the contrary, Congress follows his corrupt lead with the sycophantic allegiance reserved for a king, dictator, authoritarian, or unitary regime. All the Republicans have conspired to shield him from accountability, and they rubber-stamp his every act.

Zach Nunn is a part of that conspiracy. It is for this reason that Nunn needs to be replaced. This is true irrespective of whatever bipartisan good he may have supported. 

I have proudly voted for Sarah Trone Garriott. She will be a part of a new, sorely needed Democratic majority. 

In The New York Times Opinion Section this week, columnist Jamelle Bouie wrote:

We may well be less than a week away from a Democratic sweep of Congress. There are prominent voices within the larger Democratic coalition who think it is counterproductive, even foolish, to pivot to hearings, investigations and political accountability. In their telling, most Americans are tired of the noise. The only thing they want from Congress is good government.

I want good government, too. But good government, now or in the future, is impossible without accountability. To set that aside is to condemn the United States to another national exercise in corruption and authoritarian rule. And I would hazard that after nearly two years of abject lawlessness — including summary killings by agents of the state — there are many tens of millions of Americans who also want to hold the administration and its allies responsible for their actions.

Our nation’s experiment in executive aggrandizement has gone too far. If accountability means anything, it must mean binding both the president and the presidency with law. It is the essential task of the next Democratic majority, and the next Democratic presidency for that matter, to begin the reconstruction of American democracy with the rule of law in mind.

That Trump is something like the apotheosis of the dysfunction of the American system does not mean that he is the end of the story. He may well be the beginning of something much worse. Our job is to make him a blip in the history of American democracy and not the opening act of its demise. 

I concur with Bouie‘s call for accountability. Special counsel Jack Smith tried, but Trump found a way to slip from the jaws of law and order. What happened on January 6, 2021 was a serious crime on so many levels, and Trump avoided the consequences of his crimes … by running for president and winning. 

Fool me once (2016) shame on you. Fool me twice (2024) shame on me … for not being persuasive enough with our neighbors who think this conman should have been returned to the White House. 

Sarah Trone Garriott will stand for accountability, but Zach Nunn will not.


Top image: Screenshot from KCCI-TV’s video of the third Congressional district debate on October 27.

About the Author(s)

Gerald Ott

  • Hateful rhetoric seems to dominate

    Republican advertisements for this election. (I know that some Democratic ads are also hoping to frighten voters into electing them). Seldom do candidates look at issues that matter to all Iowans or Americans, but they are quick to stoke fear, distrust and anger from their base. Once the dust settles on this election, many of the members of the Iowa legislature will begin to hold town halls. My question for my reps will be “Do you approve of the negative advertising that was prevalent in the midterms?” If they answer “no”, I will ask them if they will stop using negative ads in their campaigns. I hope that doing this will make them accountable for the next election; I am not counting on it but I can hope.

  • The environment is playing a very small role in Iowa national races this year...

    …but not because Trump and congressional Republicans haven’t been degrading and endangering water, air, land, and wildlife in extraordinary and unprecedented ways. And Zach Nunn has been doing more than his share. His environmental voting record, as rated by the League of Conservation Voters, was 3% in 2025, with a lifetime voting record of 6%. Skimming the long list of good bills he has opposed and bad bills he has supported, just in the past few years, is truly depressing.

    Sarah Trone Garriott has demonstrated that she actually knows and cares about natural resources and the life support systems of this planet. She deserves to win!

  • To be fair

    When Gerald Ott writes, hoping to put lipstick on the pig that was Sarah Trone Garriott’s debate performance, you know Sarah did horribly in last week’s debate.

    Or, you can watch the debate on PBS, and see for yourself.

    Sarah had three points to make: Nunn does quid pro quo with billionaire donors (something that came back around to bite her in the ass), Nunn is a Trump whore and Nunn is out of touch with every day Iowans. These were not great points on which to base an argument to defeat him for a seat in Congress. They were points, nonetheless so, a fan like Gerald had to hope she would do well with them, regardless of how weak they were.

    As I just mentioned, Sarah was confronted by the fact she, herself, is being financed by one of Iowa’s only billionaires (isn’t Lamberti a billionaire or, does he just like to flaunt his mere millions?).

    Check, and mate for Nunn.

    During the most recent Iowa Down Ballot show, Kathie Obradovich also attempted to raise Sarah’s performance (since Sarah didn’t). Kathie said that Nunn has more experience (duh!) and Sarah always sounds nervous when she speaks. Of course, a nervous voice is one thing; a lack of substance in any voice, nervous or assured, is still a lack of substance.

    I think Laura Belin had it about right: she said Sarah’s campaign erred in only agreeing to one debate, and one so close in time to the election. Laura didn’t say a whole lot more than that, which was charitable.

    I’m less charitable.

    Make no mistake. I voted early, and I voted for Sarah. I like Sarah.

    At times two years ago, she apparently went through some sort of middle-age crisis, changing her hairstyle and wearing skirts more appropriate for a 20-something who hasn’t had a couple of kids, yet. To me, anyhow, she came across back then as frivolous in her fashion choices.

    But her speeches were sincere, powerful and on-the-mark.

    Her debate with Zach Nunn was none of those things.

    Which brings me back to my point: Gerald Ott here feels the need to tell us all of the stuff that Sarah didn’t tell the people who don’t know her at all. That’s not how it works. That’s her job. She did not reach that mark, let alone exceed it.

    On the matter of transgender issues, Sarah didn’t have time during the debate for the nuance required to explain herself. That was something that should have — but did not — come out in her opening statement. “You’re going to hear tonight that I support boys in girls’ sports and locker rooms. Let me take 20 seconds and tell you in advance why that is nonsense.”

    But she didn’t. She apparently didn’t anticipate being called out on it, despite the fact Nunn has been running ads about it for weeks. Apparently, she hoped she could run out the debate clock without the topic coming up.

    She was asked what cost will decrease because of her performance as a first-year Congresswoman. Her answer was, “We’re struggling from tariffs.” That left a gap as wide as an ocean for Nunn to respond by criticizing her for not having a plan. And he took full advantage of it, because she didn’t have a plan.

    She was asked how to deal with truckers and the price of diesel. Her answer was that farmers are hurting because of the price of diesel and tariffs.

    On the other hand, she did a very nice job on the matter of the war in Iran, leaving Nunn little room to dance. That wasn’t enough.

    Nunn didn’t perform well. He could only say, so many times, words like, “Look. . . here’s the reality” and “we have the receipts” (twice was enough) before being annoying.

    He isn’t old enough to pull off what he tried to pull off, which was, gravitas. He is a year younger than Sarah. Even with the cartoonish Perry White from the Superman television show gray sideburn thing, and the strained attempt to deepen his voice, he still looked the poser that he is.

    Let’s just admit it. Sarah had a bad night, and neither Gerald Ott or Kathie Obradovich or I can rewrite that history.

    It is pathetic to try, and given that we are Democrats, we can’t pull that level of dishonesty off anyhow. It isn’t in our nature. That is why we frequently get rolled, and why Sarah should have prepared for the debate more vigorously.

    Nonetheless, Nunn is the incumbent. He had it easier than Sarah. Sarah didn’t come to the debate prepared to take on an incumbent. She just did not.

Comments