Is Randy Feenstra planning to float tax credit for homeschoolers?

A new Iowa poll is testing messages about a $4,000 tax credit to help families cover “approved education expenses,” and suggests that approach may save taxpayer money currently spent on children enrolled in public schools.

It’s not clear who commissioned the text survey, which has been in the field in recent days. The questionnaire points to Randy Feenstra’s campaign for governor, which is technically still in the “exploratory” phase, or some entity planning to support Feenstra for governor. Many of the questions use preferred Republican frames (“education freedom,” parental choice, “limiting government overreach”). The poll asks how important it is for Iowa’s next governor to “work to improve K-12 education,” and tests only one potential match-up: Randy Feenstra vs. Rob Sand. (Last month, Bleeding Heartland covered a different poll testing messages about Feenstra and Sand.)

Homeschoolers are an important Republican constituency, especially among social conservatives. Families who send their kids to private schools—almost all of which are Christian or Catholic—would also welcome an education tax credit, in addition to the taxpayer assistance they already receive through Iowa’s school voucher program (“education savings accounts”).

Feenstra has good reason to search for ways to shore up his support with the “education freedom” crowd. His underwhelming victory over a little-known 2024 primary challenger highlighted troubles on his right flank. He is unpopular among property rights activists who oppose the use of eminent domain to build Summit Carbon Solutions’ proposed CO2 pipeline. He has skipped forums involving other Republican candidates for governor, including an Iowa Faith and Freedom Coalition event in July. Feenstra’s exploratory committee has the resources to pay for opinion research.

A recent poll of “likely Republican voters,” conducted by American Viewpoint, found Feenstra “in a commanding position,” with 41 percent support in the governor’s race and no other GOP candidate above 5 percent. A cautionary note: American Viewpoint’s polls for Feenstra’s U.S. House campaign found the incumbent with a roughly 50-point lead over challenger Kevin Virgil before the 2024 GOP primary. Feenstra ended up winning the nomination in Iowa’s fourth Congressional district by a margin of 60.1 percent to 39.4 percent.


What follows is the questionnaire of the new text poll (minus demographic questions), transcribed verbatim from screenshots provided by a respondent.

Note that the survey includes one ballot test for Iowa’s U.S. Senate race: Republican Ashley Hinson against Democrat Josh Turek. Hinson and Turek are also the only Senate candidates whose favorability is measured. That could indicate Hinson’s Senate campaign paid to include a question or two in a survey that is mostly about the governor’s race and state-level policies.

Alternatively, it could mean that whoever designed this poll expects the Senate race to come down to Hinson vs. Turek and wants to see whether Feenstra is performing better or worse than the likely Republican nominee for Senate.


The following are a few names of people in lowa and nationally. For each one, please
indicate if you have an unfavorable or a favorable opinion of that person. If you have
never heard of that person or don’t have an opinion, please indicate that.

  • Josh Turek
  • Donald Trump
  • Ashley Hinson
  • Kim Reynolds
  • Rob Sand
  • Randy Feenstra

(options are Very Unfavorable, Somewhat Unfavorable, Somewhat Favorable, Very Favorable, No Opinion, or Never Heard Of)

Thinking about the country, generally speaking, do you disapprove or approve of the
job Donald Trump is doing as President? (Strongly disapprove, Somewhat disapprove, Somewhat approve, Strongly approve, Don’t know)

Now, thinking ahead to 2026, how likely are you to vote in next year’s election for
governor, U.S. Congress, state legislature, and other various offices in lowa? (Definitely will not vote, Probably will not vote, It’s fifty-fifty, Probably will vote, Definitely will vote, Don’t know)

If the 2026 election for U.S. Senate were held today, for whom would you vote if the
candidates were Josh Turek, Democrat, and Ashley Hinson, Republican? (Definitely Josh Turek, Probably Josh Turek, Probably Ashley Hinson, Definitely Ashley Hinson, Someone else/Other please specify, Undecided/Don’t know, Do not plan to vote)

And, if the 2026 election for lowa Governor were held today, for whom would you vote if the candidates were Rob Sand, Democrat, and Randy Feenstra, Republican? (Definitely Rob Sand, Probably Rob Sand, Probably Randy Feenstra, Definitely Randy Feenstra, Someone else/Other please specify, Undecided/Don’t know, Do not plan to vote)

Now thinking about some issues facing lowa…In general, do you think K-12 education in lowa is heading in the wrong or right direction? (Wrong direction, Right direction, Don’t know)

How important is it that the next governor of lowa work to improve K-12 education in the state? (Not at all important, Not that important, Somewhat important, Very important, Extremely important, Don’t know)

Do you support or oppose parents, instead of the government, choosing the best school for their child(ren)? (Strongly support, Somewhat support, Somewhat oppose, Strongly oppose, Don’t know)

And, would you support or oppose a program in the state that would give K-12 families more choices and control over how they can educate their children and save taxpayers money? (Strongly support, Somewhat support, Somewhat oppose, Strongly oppose, Don’t know)

Thinking again about the election for governor next year, would you be less or more
likely to vote for a candidate if the candidate supported giving K-12 families more
choices and control over how they can educate their children and saving taxpayers
money? (Much less likely, Somewhat less likely, Somewhat more likely, Much more likely, No difference in likelihood, Don’t know)

lowa is seen nationally as a leader in education freedom. Should lawmakers in the state…? (Stop lowa’s progress and let other states catch up, Keep pushing forward and continue to lead by example, Don’t know)

As you may know, lowa has an education savings account program that lets K-12 families use funding for state-approved educational expenses like tuition, tutoring, and advanced coursework for their children. Based on what you know, do you have an unfavorable or a favorable opinion of lowa’s education savings account program? (Very unfavorable, Somewhat unfavorable, Somewhat favorable, Very favorable, Don’t know)

Thinking about tax credits, would you support or oppose lowa offering K-12 families a $4,000 tax credit that they could use for the educational purposes of a child? (Strongly support, Somewhat support, Somewhat oppose, Strongly oppose, Don’t know)

The following are a few statements about this potential tax credit. For each statement, please indicate if it makes you less or more favorable to offering K-12 families a $4,000 tax credit that they could use to help educate a child. (options for all are Much less favorable, Neither more nor less favorable, Somewhat less favorable, Somewhat more favorable, Much more favorable, Don’t know)

A new program providing K-12 families a tax credit would provide greater access to high-quality educational options.

Iowa spends about $17,000 in taxpayer money every year to educate each child at a public school. By giving families a $4,000 tax credit to help pay for approved education expenses, we can better educate our children while also saving taxpayers the remaining $13,000.

lowa has a lot of great schools, but they look the same as they did decades ago. A tax credit would help attract innovative and more modern schools to lowa.

An education tax credit would position lowa at the forefront of President Trump’s initiative to “support parents in choosing and directing the upbringing and education of their children.”

A tax credit would provide families with more education freedom while limiting government overreach.

Having read more, would you support or oppose lowa offering K-12 families a $4,000 tax credit that they could use for the educational purposes of a child?

About the Author(s)

Laura Belin

  • This post is a good reminder...

    …of why, when the time comes, I will vote in the Democratic primary for whichever candidate seems most able and likely to defeat Feenstra.

  • apologies if I missed something obvious in the questionnaire

    but how would this savings for taxpayers work (is this the homeschooling part) ?
    “Iowa spends about $17,000 in taxpayer money every year to educate each child at a public school. By giving families a $4,000 tax credit to help pay for approved education expenses, we can better educate our children while also saving taxpayers the remaining $13,000.”

    Every time Dems move rightward on issues from immigration to expanding private education this gives MAGA permission to get even more extreme in their pitches to voters by way of Dems giving credibility to their claims of broken government and crisis.

    • No title

      That is how I interpreted the question: they are suggesting that if more families homeschool, Iowa could give them a $4,000 tax credit instead of spending $17,000 on each of their kids in public school.

      Of course incentivizing families to pull kids out of public schools would hasten the demise of many school districts.

    • No title

      I’m not aware of Iowa Democrats calling for expanding private education. Every single Democrat in the Iowa House and Senate voted against the school voucher bill.

  • thanks I guessed that was it but wasn't clear

    ha yeah in terms of government accounting tax cuts are a kind of spending (way of giving government money to people) and as you note to the destruction of schools, like how they killing hospitals with other cuts in spending. Vouchers and charter schools are both ways of shifting public dollars into private hands (and promoting “Choice”) and many Dems across the country support some of each , see the mayoral race in NYC for a prominent example of the division among Dems.
    I know some Dems here in Iowa are explicitly against public funds for private management and others not so much…
    In your question to Rob Sand about whether or not he would vote as a parent for more money for his school district he blamed presidents from both parties for cuts in schools spending, aside from his general campaign strategy of taking shots at Dems any idea what he is talking about, how did Biden cut money for Iowa schools?

    • No title

      That’s not how I interpreted his comment. He didn’t accuse Biden of cutting money for Iowa schools. He accused the legislature of failing to fund schools in a way that would keep up with inflation. He said we’ve seen that in two presidencies but actually, even going back to the early 2010s, the legislature’s school funding has not kept pace with inflation.

  • ah so

    the comment about “two different administration, two different parties” was shot about inflation and so they hurt the schools that way? gotcha thanks
    Appreciate him supporting taxing the public to pay for public schools, hope he will be as explicit about how he plans to refund other public services.

  • Message testing and homeschool winning

    It makes sense to me that Feenstra is message testing. His only message so far has been “He’s tall!”

    Tax credits for homeschooling is going to be an easier sell than tax credits for private schools because it takes the class argument out of it. Can’t point to Dowling’s football field or Pella Christian’s lovely school building and say “that’s where all your tax money went”. Also, it’s going to be a much easier sell to the rural constituents who don’t have a private school within an hours drive.

    Honestly, I’m surprised there wasn’t a bigger push for homeschool tax credits when the original bill came around.

  • SharpHawkeye

    I think you’re being just a little unfair to Randy Feenstra. He has also been pushing a second message. “I’ve got fabulous teeth!”

  • 5 out of 5 dentists agree

    PrairieFan, you’re exactly right, he does have a fantastic set of chompers, doesn’t he!

  • SharpHawkeye

    The thought of him as governor is causing me to grind my own.

Comments